
People put up with the SPL because it is like a rag-tag sports movie. Two members carry the league to some sort of veiled credibility: Rangers and Celtic, the rest are a hodgepodge of try hards, misfits and has beens. In this movie, Rangers and Celtic alternatively play the hero and the villain. Theoretically, the whole of the country can get behind the Old Firm as they battle on against teams above and beyond their ability in Europe, but they also play the villain in that their financial resources are so much greater than the other members of the league, so a talent drain develops where teams like Hibs and Dundee United become almost a hybrid-feeder team to the Old Firm. Teams have to suffer the indignity of their great white hope returning to his former battleground and not even giving them the honour of one final battle against their former club. Instead they have to watch their Great White hope as he languishes on one of the Old Firms benches.
On the other end of the spectrum from the undeniable comparative financial clout of the Old Firm lies Gretna. Gretna Football club has been run like an A-Level business management worst-case scenario case study since Brooks Mileson takes over. Class: An ageing invalid, football obsessed millionaire with lofty aspirations and little patience wants to take over a football club. He wants to reach the dizzy heights of the SPL before he pops his clogs so is going to treat the club like a rollercoaster, He will drain the clubs finances by paying for players above and beyond his means, meanwhile as this occurs he will refuse to address the glaring problems of a) the stadium and b) the people who fill the stadium. What will happen kids?
The Borders are a traditionally Rugby obsessed area, yet this didn’t even stop the Borders Rugby team from folding. What made Brooks Mileson believe he could garner enough support from this area to make a football team in the area a success where the Rugby team failed? His own greed and blinkered ambition. As Gretna closed its eyes and ran headfirst through the leagues, the stadium still failed to make the requirements for the first division, despite the fact that I imagine my back garden reaches the requirements for a first division stadium.
To combat this, once Gretna reached the SPL they played at Fir Park, the home stadium of Motherwell Football Club. This highlights the absolute farce by which Gretna had become, not only did they have little support in Gretna, but they had now arranged for even Gretna’s home games to be an almighty trek, while also nullifying any home team advantage, The home team advantage later manifested itself via the fact that Gretna could train in a sewer to prepare them for home matches.
Mileson lost £8 Million on Gretna, he is now too ill to have control of his own finances. Who knows the financial dire straits the Mileson would be suffering if he were currently in charge of his own finances. The talk has since turned to bailouts, if not from the Scottish executive then from the SFA or SPL. The only reasons being to cover up an almighty embarrassment and to stop the fixture congestion from being thrown into further disarray if all Gretna’s matches were to be considered nullified, if Gretna went bankrupt.
The sad story of this is that this isn’t even strange for an SPL club, in noughties alone, Gretna will be the fourth SPL club to go into administration, after Motherwell in 2002, Dundee in 2003 and Livingston in 2004. If anything was a convincing argument for the old-firm to break away from the SPL into either the Premiership or the Atlantic league, it has to be that the infrastructure of the SPL does not only not produce successful football teams, but it also is incapable of ensuring sustainable businesses. Rangers and Celtic currently therefore are following the Barry Ferguson model of ensuring that they play against inferior opposition so they can maintain their schoolyard bully status.
The integrity of the game is called into place if teams like Gretna can ignore the league’s rules on stadiums while they have a wage bill of over £50,000, which, while they were in the first division, was 3 times that of nearest competitors St. Johnstone, who funnily enough had a SPL ready stadium. In football, due to the vast array of ways to enter into the league, a salary cap would not really be possible, but the SPL have to police this side of the game better if the league is to be a success in any way.
Gretna have now had to release their players and they don’t have a stadium. The poster boy for the rise and rise of Gretna, the good Dr. Kenny Deuchar, is now living the dream of playing in the MLS. Gretna could not guarantee past wages for their players so as fragile as the career of an average footballer is, it was morally unjust to expect any of these players to risk injury without any financial compensation.
As I watched Sports Relief, I was slightly disappointed to see that the plight of Gretna was being ignored. I am also disappointed that nobody has seen the answer to Gretna’s problems staring them in the face. How much money would various football fanatic businessmen pay to play against their heroes in the SPL? I imagine for Gretna’s game against Celtic, Gretna could have found 11 men willing to pay £25,000 each for the joy of playing against Celtic. Gretna are already a complete and utter joke, why not make them a joke that are financially capable?
I hope Brooks gets better, and whatever he did with Gretna, it is the league’s fault for letting it happen. Brooks just wanted to build a successful team as quick as he could because his past shows that he loved football, he probably did what most of us would do if we had his money. It just proves that chairman need to find a middle ground, they cannot be money throwing obsessive who feed on control, nor can they be detached cold hearted people who treat the team as nothing but a business. But if I had to choose between those two, I’d choose Brooks every time. GET WELL SOON CHUM. Maybe you shouldn’t have been so hasty in selling Kenny Deuchar though, always handy to have a doctor around.